A new job two states away, a move in with a partner, a growing family that needs more room. Whatever the reason, you are leaving the house, and the question is whether to cash out or keep it as a rental. Should I sell or rent my house? In Massachusetts the answer usually turns on three things national advice skips: a federal tax clock that starts running the day you move out, state landlord rules that are stricter than most, and how much of your own time you can give a property you no longer live in.
Here is the short version. If you lived in the house for two of the last five years, you can typically exclude up to $250,000 of gain from tax, or $500,000 for a married couple filing jointly, but only if you sell within that five-year window. Rent it for more than about three years and that exclusion can disappear. Renting makes sense when the rent comfortably covers every cost and you are prepared to be a Massachusetts landlord. Selling makes sense when either of those is doubtful.
The three routes, side by side
Most owners are really choosing between three options, not two: list it and sell, keep it and rent it out, or sell it as it stands for a quick close.
| Sell on the open market | Rent it out | Sell as-is for cash | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Money in hand | Highest price, after commission and repairs | None up front, monthly income if rent beats costs | Lower price, no repairs or showings |
| Your time | Weeks of prep, showings and negotiation | Ongoing: tenants, repairs, rules, taxes | Least, one walkthrough |
| Tax exclusion | Usually kept if you qualify | Kept only if you sell within the window | Usually kept if you qualify |
| Main risk | Market softens while listed | Vacancy, damage, a tenant who will not leave | Leaving some price on the table |
| Timing | Longer, since most buyers need a mortgage | Indefinite | Usually 2 to 4 weeks once title is clear |
None of these is right for everyone. The rest of this article walks through what actually decides it.
The tax clock most owners miss
This is the factor that most often changes the decision, and it is fixed by federal law, not by the market. According to IRS Publication 523, you meet the tests for the full home sale exclusion if you owned the home and used it as your residence for at least 24 months of the 5 years leading up to the date of sale. The 24 months do not have to be continuous.
That gives you a window. An owner who lived in the house for two years before moving out can generally rent it for up to about three years and still sell with the exclusion intact. Past that point, the lookback no longer holds two years of residence, and the gain can become taxable. On a Massachusetts house bought a decade ago, that can be a large number.
Two other rules are worth knowing before you sign a lease.
- Depreciation comes back at sale. Publication 523 says you cannot exclude the part of your gain equal to depreciation allowed or allowable after May 6, 1997. Landlords are generally expected to depreciate a rental, so a few years of renting typically leaves a slice of gain that is taxable even if the rest is excluded
- A job move can help if you are short of two years. If you have not yet lived there for two years, a partial exclusion may still apply when the move is work related, for example a new job at least 50 miles farther from the home than your old one
Tax outcomes depend on your full picture, so run your own numbers with a tax professional before deciding. The point here is simply that “rent it for a while and sell later” has a deadline built in.
What renting actually involves in Massachusetts
Massachusetts landlord law is detailed, and it applies to an accidental landlord renting out a former home just as it does to a professional.
Start with money you can collect. Under chapter 186, section 15B, at the start of a tenancy you generally cannot require more than first month’s rent, last month’s rent at the same rate, and a security deposit no larger than one month’s rent. A security deposit must be held in a separate interest-bearing account at a bank in Massachusetts, the tenant must get a receipt within 30 days naming the bank and account, and the landlord owes the tenant interest each year of the tenancy at 5 percent or the lower rate the bank actually pays. Failing to hold the deposit this way entitles the tenant to its immediate return, which is why a landlord-tenant attorney’s review of your first lease is money well spent.
Then look at the age of the house. Under the state lead law, chapter 111, section 197, whenever a child under six lives in a home with dangerous levels of lead in paint, plaster or other accessible surfaces, the owner must abate or contain it. Massachusetts anti-discrimination law also generally prevents a landlord from refusing to rent to a family because they have children, with narrow exceptions. In practice, an older house you rent out may need lead work you never had to think about as an owner-occupant, and the cost falls on you. Talk to a licensed lead inspector about what an older house is likely to need.
Finally, getting the house back is slow if a tenancy goes wrong. Massachusetts does not allow self-help, and removing a tenant requires a court case. Our walkthrough of selling a house with a tenant who refuses to leave sets out each stage, and it is worth reading before you sign a first lease, not after.
Should I sell or rent my house if the numbers are close?
If the numbers are close, selling is usually the safer call. Rent has to cover the mortgage, property taxes, insurance at landlord rates, repairs, periods with no tenant, and either a property manager’s fee or your own time. A house that only breaks even on paper tends to lose money once one furnace, one vacancy or one slow-paying tenant arrives.
It helps to be honest about why renting appeals. Sometimes it is a strong rent-to-cost ratio in a town where you would happily own a rental. Just as often it is a hope that prices will rise, or a reluctance to sell a house with emotional weight. Those are real reasons, but they are not a rental business plan.
We hear this from the other side. Landlord and tenant problems are behind roughly 15 percent of the sellers who contact us, and in our experience about a quarter to a third of the people we talk to are on their second plan: they tried something first, such as listing or holding on, and it did not work out.
When selling now is the better route
Selling tends to win when you have a real gain and are near the edge of the five-year window, when the house needs work that a landlord would have to fund anyway, when you are moving far enough away that managing it remotely is impractical, or when you need the equity for the next house.
If you are selling because of a move, our guide to selling your Massachusetts home when relocating out of state covers what can be signed remotely and what has to be done before you leave. And if you want a firm number to set against the rental math, you can request a cash offer on your house and compare it with what a listing and a lease would realistically net.
Homeowners We’ve Helped
Boston Investors
-
After 94 days on the market, two buyers backed out over the roof and septic. We were tired of dealing with it. The cash offer came without asking us to make the repairs, and we closed in 21 days. Once we looked at the actual numbers, it made much more sense than continuing to list. The whole process was simple and we’re very happy with how it worked out.
